Testing the Quality and Durability of Concrete in Seconds with Surf™

As the demand for new concrete structures continues to boom, better and more efficient ways to test the quality and durability of concrete are needed. Multiple tests for obtaining and understanding concrete durability by measuring its ability to resist chloride penetration have widely become accepted. This method, commonly known as RCPT (rapid chloride permeability test), measures chloride penetration on a range from high to negligible and is standardized by ASTM C1202: Standard Test Method for Electrical Indication of Concrete’s Ability to Resist Chloride Ion Penetration. This test is especially important for DOT’s when bridges and highways are undergoing construction, as well as for monitoring existing structures to determine and prevent deterioration of concrete and rebar corrosion due to chloride penetration.

Unfortunately, not only is the RCPT approach labor intensive, it is also time-consuming, as the test itself takes 6 hours to complete and requires extensive sample preparation. This includes cutting and conditioning the samples into a desiccator for 3 hours and letting the specimens soak with water for 18 hours prior to the test, and even more steps. Moreover, this test method is often very expensive due to the amount of work required to perform the analysis.

Using Electrical Resistivity to Test the Durability of Concrete

A much faster and less expensive method for determining the quality and durability of concrete is electrical resistivity. Electrical resistivity has been used to measure the quality of concrete since the early 1910s, but in recent years state of the art devices have been developed to improve this measurement process. This method assesses the ability of concrete to resist a chloride passage by measuring the concrete’s resistance to the flow of electrical current. As a result, it evaluates the quality control and service life prediction of concrete.

Electrical resistivity testing can be used to:

  • Ensure quality
  • Measure chloride permeability
  • Determine the Chloride Diffusion Coefficient
  • Detect cracks
  • Determine the setting time of fresh concrete
  • Measure moisture content

Learn more about the science behind how electrical resistivity evaluates the quality of concrete.

Methods of Measuring Electrical Resistivity of Concrete

Different techniques for measuring electrical resistivity of concrete, include bulk resistivity, surface resistivity, and embedded electrodes for fresh concrete.

Bulk Resistivity: ASTM C1876, AASHTO TP 119 & CSA 23.3-26C. Two electrodes are used to send and read the current flow in a hardened concrete sample using two parallel electrode plates which transmit an alternate current (AC).

Embedded Electrodes in Fresh Concrete: embedded electrodes are used to track changes in the concrete hydration process, enabling the user to measure water content, predict concrete setting time, and detect cracking.

Surface Resistivity: AASHTO T358. Uses the Wenner-Array setup in which four electrodes are positioned in a straight line and equally spaced. The two outer electrodes send the current into the concrete, while the two inner electrodes measure the concrete’s electrical potential.

The Time-Savings Potential of Surface Resistivity

surf
The Giatec Surf used to measure surface electrical resistivity in concrete. This utilizes the Wenner Probe technique.

All of these methods of testing concrete quality and durability are valid. However, the potential of electrical resistivity, in particular; surface resistivity to monitor your concrete, yields huge advantages. This is especially true when compared to current chloride permeability tests.

The RCPT method takes 6 hours for test results to be returned, not to mention the additional time needed to prep concrete samples for testing. But, with surface electrical resistivity testing, according to AASHTO T358: Surface Resistivity Indication of Concrete’s Ability to Resist Chloride Ion Penetration, you can evaluate the quality and permeability of your concrete in seconds. This saves significant time in both labor costs and quality control testing costs for DOTs and testing agencies. States such as Florida and Louisiana have already realized the significant cost savings associated with this testing method and have incorporated it in their specifications.

Giatec’s Surf™ device is the fastest and most accurate technology for the measurement of surface resistivity.
Surf can be used to evaluate;

  • Performance-based quality control of concrete
  • Estimation of chloride diffusion coefficient of concrete
  • Service life design of concrete structures
  • Estimation of the remaining life of concrete structures
  • Crack detection in concrete elements under load
  • Monitor the setting time of fresh concrete

Surf™ has a unique and customized setup, which enables the measurement of electrical resistivity with high accuracy by reducing the duration of the test, minimizing the ambient effects and reducing human error. The patented technology automatically measures resistivity 8 times around the concrete specimen using four channels of 4-probe array which are located at 90° from each other. These measurements are used to estimate the resistance of chloride penetration in the concrete.

Chloride Penetrability Classification
Chloride Ion Penetrability AASHTO T358: Surface Resistivity (kohm-cm)

a = 1.5 in.

ASTM C1202 – Rapid Chloride Penetrability (Coulombs)
4-by-8 in. (100-by-200-mm) 6-by-12 in. (150-by-300-mm)
High <12 <9.5 > 4000
Moderate 12-21 9.5-16.5 2000-4000
Low 21-37 16.5-29 1000-2000
Very Low 37-254 29-199 100-1000
Negligible >254 >199 <100

a = Wenner probe tip spacing

surface electrical resistivity
Schematic view of surface electrical resistivity.

This shows the qualitative relationship between the rapid chloride penetrability test (RCPT), and the surface electrical resistivity of concrete. This device can also be used for durability-based quality control of concrete and for monitoring the service life design of a structure.

Electrical resistivity testing is an important step in the process of assessing durability factors of concrete, such as permeability, diffusivity, and other micro-structure characteristics which can be correlated to other properties, such as; chloride diffusion coefficient, water absorption, and the rate of corrosion of rebar in reinforced structures.

These characteristics provide, not only a quantitative assessment of concrete, but also general guidance on the current durability status of any given concrete element. This technology has the potential to save significant costs associated with testing and labor for DOTs, testing agencies, and contractors.

2 Responses

  1. Hi Vijay,

    From your electrical resistivity values you can refer to the following paper as a guide to build a correlation between diffusion coefficient and conductivity (the inverse value of resisitivity):

    https://www.giatecscientific.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Concrete_Electrical_Resistivity.pdf

    Please note that we only suggest this paper as a general guide, given the limitations from the experiment (i.e. 20 concrete mixtures were tested). Diffusion coefficient and conductivity are subject to variations depending on your concrete mixture, cement type, etc. You can relate to the linear relationship from the Nernst-Einstein equation (concrete in SSD condition) to build the diffusion coefficient relationship. Furthermore, to estimate service life of concrete, there are some available software that could help you with that, such as Life365.

    Please feel free to email us at support@giatec.ca if you need further details.

  2. We have iCOR from which we can evaluate surface resistivity.
    Can you please guide us on how to find the chloride diffusion coefficient from electrical resistivity and the service life of concrete?
    Thanks
    Vijay Kulkarni India

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

giatec award for best paper

Giatec Award for Best Paper

We are very excited to announce the launch of our annual research paper contest! This is a great opportunity for civil-engineers to expose their research and development to a global audience of industry experts. Plus, the…

Schematic representation of service-life stages for structures exposed to chloride-induced corrosion risk

Analyzing Corrosion in Reinforced Concrete Structures

Reinforced concrete structures have shaped our cities for thousands of years, from historical buildings stretching as far back as the Romans to present day, such as the 3-storey parking garage adjacent to the mega shopping mall…

Concrete Robot

Concrete-Eating Robots – The Future of Recycling Old Buildings

The process of demolishing a building involves heavy machinery to crush concrete and separate valuable materials that can be reused. Current methods consume quite a significant amount of time and money in order to safely disassemble the building, extract parts, and transport the materials to off-site centers…

rcon

Why Measure Concrete Resistivity?

Concrete is a porous material which contains microscopic voids known as pores. These pores range in size, vary in connectivity (pore structure) and can be added to the concrete via air-entraining admixtures. The water-to-cementitious material and…

completed road

Open Roads Sooner with Concrete Curing Sensors

Road construction can be a lengthy, disruptive process—so ensuring that your project stays on schedule is one of your most important responsibilities as a project manager. *For eligible new customers only Get a Free Trial Kit…

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience, analyze site traffic and assist in our marketing efforts. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy Page.