Rebound Hammer vs. The Maturity Method: Which Should You Choose?

Aerial view of construction site
Aerial view of construction site

Schmidt/Rebound Hammer Method

Rebound hammer test


The concrete rebound hammer test (often referred to as Schmidt Hammer) was invented in 1948 and is still a popular choice to test the compressive strength of concrete. To use this method, the concrete rebound hammer must first be calibrated against a steel test anvil. Once calibrated, a spring release mechanism is used to activate a hammer which impacts a plunger to drive into the surface of the concrete. After impact, the plunger is locked in its retracted position and a rebound number is recorded (the numbers can range from 10-100). For accuracy, several numbers must be recorded.

Get Your First SmartRock Concrete Sensor for FREE

Giatec SR demo kit_
Giatec SR demo kit_

In order to establish a relationship between the rebound number and the compressive strength of concrete, the following two methods are often used: ACI 228.1: In Place Methods to Estimate Concrete Strength, or BS EN 13791:2019: Assessment of In-Situ Compressive Strength in Structures and Precast Concrete Components.

The Principle of the Schmidt/Rebound Hammer Test

According to The Constructor the concrete “rebound hammer test method is based on the principle that the rebound of an elastic mass depends on the hardness of the concrete surface against which the mass strikes.” In other words, the amount of rebound recorded using the hammer will depend on the hardness of the concrete surface, which will then correlate to the compressive strength of the concrete.

Pros of the Schmidt/Rebound Hammer Method

  • The device is easy and convenient to use.
  • This test can be done directly onsite.

Cons of the Schmidt/Rebound Hammer Method

  • This study by Sanchez and Tarranza found that the Schmidt Hammer Test is influenced by a number of external factors such as moisture and temperature. They found that this test should not substitute obtaining the actual compressive strength of concrete, and that the rebound curve generally underestimates the actual compressive strength of concrete.
  • You often need to use another testing method to confirm the data.
  • The device itself requires regular cleaning.
  • The results from the test are based on a local point.
  • The concrete surface must be prepared before testing and be smooth, clean, and dry.

The Maturity Method

concrete maturity strength relationship

The maturity method is a non-destructive testing method that allows you to estimate the early-age and compressive strength of in-place concrete in real-time. It is defined by ASTM C1074: The Standard Practice for Estimating Concrete Strength by the Maturity Method, as “a technique for estimating concrete strength that is based on the assumption that samples of a given concrete mixture attain equal strengths if they attain equal values of the maturity index.” The maturity index value considers concrete temperature and curing time. Concrete maturity sensors like SmartRock® can be used to collect the necessary data.

Before you can use your sensors or maturity meter on-site, you must complete a calibration process. The calibration creates a unique relationship between the Maturity Index (obtained using the temperature profile) and concrete strength. A maturity calibration only needs to be completed once for a specific mix and its properties, and this blog breaks down the entire process. Once you have calibrated your mix, you can begin your project using the maturity method.

There are many different types of concrete sensors, each with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. SmartRock sensors have been trusted in over 8,200 jobsites worldwide and are a great choice to track maturity. These sensors are installed in 3 easy steps:

smartrock
  1. Tag your sensor. You must activate the sensor and tag it in your SmartRock mobile app.
  2. Install your sensor directly on the rebar, and then pour your concrete as usual.
  3. View your results in real-time using the SmartRock app.
    The embedded sensor measures the temperature of the concrete at specific time intervals and then calculates the concrete’s strength/maturity by using the calibration data previously inputted by the user.

The Principle of the Maturity Method

The maturity method is based on the principle that concrete strength is directly related to its hydration temperature history. The standards outlined in ASTM C1074 are most commonly used. This standard provides the Nurse-Saul function and the Arrhenius function. The Nurse-Saul method is the more popular of the two, and it is based on the principle that there is a linear relationship between the maturity and the temperature in real time. The underlying assumption is that the strength development in concrete is a linear function of hydration temperature.

Click here for more details on the maturity method!

Pros of the Maturity Method

  • The maturity method proves to be accurate and reliable, providing real-time data.
  • Not only does the sensor work in any type of weather or condition, the data can help you decide when to take measures to heat or cool your concrete.If using a fully embedded sensor, there is no need to worry about it being damaged onsite, and there is no maintenance required.

Cons of the Maturity Method

  • Requires a one-time calibration for each concrete mix using cylinder break tests.

Which Method of Testing Should You Choose: Schmidt/Rebound Hammer or the Maturity Method?

Now that you have read the pros and cons for both methods, you have all the information you need to decide what you will use on your next project. You may have noticed that the rebound hammer and the maturity method have a couple of similarities. Both are non-destructive methods, which is a major advantage, but both require a calibration process, which could be inconvenient. However, the concrete Schmidt/rebound hammer method may not always be accurate, so it is recommended that you supplement this test with additional methods. Whereas the maturity method is very accurate, and the method is even standardized in a growing number of countries. Therefore, if you want a method that is simple to use, accurate, and works in any condition, the maturity method and wireless sensors may be the best choice for you.

Sources

American Concrete Institute
BSI
The Constructor
Reliability of Rebound Hammer Test in Concrete Compressive Strength Estimation

**Editor’s Note: This post was originally published on September 2020 and has been updated for accuracy and comprehensiveness.

2 Responses

  1. To whom… :
    Our developments and construction projects are based out of Chicago; however, we do reach to out to other select metro markets nationally. Please share what projects local to the Chicago metro area and possibly the concrete subcontractor(s) have performed their services with The Maturity Method and the respectable sensors. In addition, which concrete designs; poured-in-place, post-tension, etc.? Additionally, were test cylinders still mandated to support the data for the respective projects and did they prove out?
    Thank you, Michael

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Articles

New Giatec 360 Updates – Part 2: Graph Customization Tools

This article will continue on the topic discussed in Part 1, be sure to check it out! Get Your First SmartRock Concrete Sensor for FREE Free Demo Kit Display The max and min temperature limits can be assigned to a sensor using the Parameter Thresholds function on both the app and the web platform of Giatec 360. When assigned, these limits are represented in the form of fine lines in red (max limit) and blue (min limit) color.  Using the 360 dashboard, a user can choose…

New Giatec 360 Updates – Part 1: Temperature, Strength, and Maturity Charts

As part of Giatec’s continued efforts and goal to meet customer requirements and expectations, progressive changes are being made to the system to better comply with updating needs. Working with clients on a global scale, we strive to provide a streamlined platform that is one place for all. With the feedback collected from our valued customers several updates and transitions have been made to the Giatec 360 program, especially the ‘Charts’. To learn what the updated site has to offer and how beneficial this can be…

Giatec Family Laptop Top Down

Level Up Your Project Reports With Giatec 360™ – Part 2

Let’s dive deeper into report generation to learn more about how Giatec 360’s reports help you make better decisions faster on the jobsite. For an introduction to Giatec 360, click to read Part 1 of this blog. Get Your First SmartRock Concrete Sensor for FREE Free Demo Kit Giatec 360 – An Overview Some of the key features are as listed as follows:   Temperature Differential Analysis  Generating Full PDF/CSV Reports  Customizing the reports as per user’s preferences which includes   Generating reports for a specific data range …

Claim Your Free Demo Kit

Get Your First SmartRock Concrete Sensor for FREE

Get Real-Time Data with SmartRock®

See how it works today

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience, analyze site traffic and assist in our marketing efforts. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy Page.