Toward the Prediction of Pore Volumes and Freeze-Thaw Performance of Concrete Using Thermodynamic Modelling

Winner of the Best Paper Award
Winner of the Best Paper Award

Congratulations to the winner of the Giatec Award for Best Paper, Keshav Bharadwaj of Oregon State University!

Title: Toward the Prediction of Pore Volumes and Freeze-Thaw Performance of Concrete Using Thermodynamic Modelling

Authors: Keshav Bharadwaj, Deborah Glosser, Mehdi Khanzadeh Moradllo, O. Burkan Isgor, W. Jason Weiss

Synopsis

Concrete is a porous material consisting of pores ranging from the nanometer scale up to the millimeter or centimeter scale. Many important properties of concrete are related to its porosity and the volumetric distribution of the pores. For example, historically, empirical models that relate the water-to-cement ratio (w/c) of concrete to achieve a target strength were used, as the w/c is often a surrogate for porosity in simple Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) systems. In modern times, several supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) are used along with OPC as they offer cost and performance benefits when compared to pure OPC systems. When SCMs are used in concrete, the drawback of empirical approaches that relate the water-to-binder ratio (w/b) of concrete to the strength is evident as the chemistry of reactions of OPC and OPC+SCM systems are different.

So, the question is, how do we predict the strength and other properties of concrete made with OPC and SCMs? One way is to understand the chemical reactions that take place in these cementitious systems. To this end, thermodynamic modeling is a very powerful tool that has been extensively validated and used to predict the reaction products and pore solution chemistry of OPC+SCM systems. Our research group at OSU works on developing models that relate the microstructure of concrete to its engineering performance.

The research group has developed a model called the PPM (Pore Partitioning Model) that calculates the volumes of different sizes of pores in pastes made of OPC+SCMs based on the reaction products obtained from thermodynamic modeling. In this work, a new model is proposed that scales the PPM to concrete. The model, dubbed the “PPMC” (Pore Partitioning Model for Concrete; outlined in Figure 1), can be used to predict the porosity and pore volumes in concrete and predict several key performance properties, such as the porosity, strength, pore connectivity, and formation factor, time to critical saturation. A sample illustration of the capabilities of this model is shown in Figure 2, where the formation factor of saturated concrete of different w/c at varying air contents is predicted.

Figure 1. Outline of the PPMC framework.
Figure 1. Outline of the PPMC framework.
 Figure 2. Predicted formation factors of OPC concrete systems.
Figure 2. Predicted formation factors of OPC concrete systems.

The formation factor of concrete is a very useful microstructural property to predict, as it is linked to the engineering performance of concrete. The formation factor can be used to predict chloride diffusion, water absorption, bulk resistivity etc. of concrete. In this work, the formation factor is used to predict the time to freeze-thaw damage in concrete systems made of OPC and OPC + Fly Ash to illustrate the power of this model. The predicted time to critical saturation (time to potential onset of freeze-thaw damage) is shown in figure 3 when a typical fly ash is used (composition and reactivity available in the full paper). One potential practical application of the PPMC framework is to determine the required volume of air entrainment to achieve a target life against freeze-thaw damage for a given concrete mixture. For example, a 20% replacement of OPC with the fly ash would require 1%-2% more entrained air to achieve the same freeze-thaw performance. The proposed approach can also be used to optimize the replacement of OPC with SCMs and air entrainment to meet the target durability requirements.

Figure 3. Predicted time to critical saturation for concrete made of OPC and Fly Ash for different volumes of entrained air.
Figure 3. Predicted time to critical saturation for concrete made of OPC and Fly Ash for different volumes of entrained air.

Read the full paper here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Use These Tech Tools for More Efficient Cold Weather Concreting

Let’s dive into our sensors in detail.   Learn More SmartRock Sensors:    SmartRock is a wireless concrete sensor designed for temperature and strength monitoring with the ability to record real-time temperature data for every 15-minute interval for 2 months and comes with remote-monitoring capabilities. It is fast, simple, designed rugged and waterproof, and can be activated and installed hassle-free. The sensor contains two points of temperature measurements located in the sensor cable and body, and comes with an extended temperature cable and probe for mass concrete purposes. This sensor can measure temperature as low as -22℉ (-30℃) with an accuracy range of ±1℃.   The SmartRock sensor, containing a black box, a…

Everything You Need to Know About Pouring Concrete in Winter

Winter is coming! Worried about the cold weather concreting that comes with it in the construction industry? We’ve got it covered with Giatec’s SmartRock sensors.  Keep reading to learn more.  Learn More The temperature is dropping, the days start to get shorter, and frost covers the ground. While it may be exciting to imagine a festive winter season, that is not what comes to mind when working in the construction industry. Especially, when you have a project to complete, a schedule to maintain, and a desired concrete temperature and strength to achieve; the pressure is on when dealing with factors like freezing of concrete at an early age, rapid temperature changes, all…

Giatec’s Unique Concrete Knowledge Resources

The Giatec Scientific website is a treasure trove of concrete knowledge, ranging from blogs and case studies to podcasts and videos! Find a few of our exclusive resources below: Learn More Giatec’s Concrete Terminology Search Bar Need a one-stop destination for searching definitions for a plethora of terms related to concrete knowledge? Make sure to check out our concrete terminology search bar! To search for a term related to cement or concrete, just type a word in the search bar. Try rebar, rodding, aggregates, cracking, or…

Essential Guide for World of Concrete!

January 18-20, 2022 | Las Vegas

Visit us at Booth #N1253

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience, analyze site traffic and assist in our marketing efforts. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy Page.