The Sinking Millennial Tower – AKA the Modern-Day Leaning Tower

Sinking Millennium Tower

In early November of 2016, news broke that one of the United States’ most luxurious residential towers are sinking and tilting – which has led to residents filing lawsuits against the city of San Francisco.

SmartRock™ Plus Sensor
*For eligible new customers only

Get a Free Trial Kit

  • Free Sensor*
  • Free Shipping
  • No Strings

According to testimony heard at City Hall on Thursday, February 2, 2017, the developers behind the sinking Millennium Tower had paid for an independent review of the tower itself prior to construction, however not for the site itself. The Millennium Partners and its engineering consultants hired Jack Moehle, a professor of structural engineering at UC Berkeley, to conduct the independent peer-review of the building design and as such, the Government Audit and Oversight committee had a few questions for him.

During Thursday’s hearing, Moehle explained that he inspected the high-rise design from top to bottom but no lower than the bottom and that a geotechnical review (a review of the condition of the soil under which the structure would be erected) was never part of the process – as no geotechnical engineers were hired. “My interest went as far as the concrete mat”, states Moehle.

The condition of the soil that structures are to be built on is important to evaluate pre-construction – especially for buildings that use foundation designs which rely on the properties of the soil to keep the building in place (i.e. concrete pillars wedged into the ground). An analogy put forth by an Iowa State design professor, aids in the understanding of how this design works. That is, one way to look at it is to think of a broomstick being wedged into a mound of beach sand. The properties of the sand, as well as the depth that the broomstick is wedged, are the two key components in ensuring that the broomstick stays in place.

Without an adequate analysis of the sand’s properties, there is no basis to go on in determining how far beneath the surface the broomstick needs to be wedged. The same can be said for soil properties and concrete pillars.

Another prime example of the leaning tower phenomenon is the famous Leaning Tower of Pisa. Similarly, the Pisa skyscraper leans to one side due to the fact that the foundation was built on soft ground that could not adequately support the weight and keep the structure in place.

The question remains… how have we not learned from our historical mistakes?

Though via email, a spokesperson for Millennium Partners affirmed that by paying for an independent review the Mission Street Development met all requirements of the city, it is clear that by failing to hire a geotechnical engineer to evaluate the soil at the Millennium Tower jobsite, the structural integrity of the building is now suffering greatly.

It is pivotal to approve the structural design, but this is just one piece of the puzzle. Let the sinking Millennial Tower be a reminder that there are many pieces of the puzzle that need to be positioned just so in order for us to optimize the execution of our concrete construction projects.

Source: Engineers Believe They Have a Fix for San Fran’s Sinking, Tilting High Rise

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

giatec award for best paper

Giatec Award for Best Paper

We are very excited to announce the launch of our annual research paper contest! This is a great opportunity for civil-engineers to expose their research and development to a global audience of industry experts. Plus, the…

Schematic representation of service-life stages for structures exposed to chloride-induced corrosion risk

Analyzing Corrosion in Reinforced Concrete Structures

Reinforced concrete structures have shaped our cities for thousands of years, from historical buildings stretching as far back as the Romans to present day, such as the 3-storey parking garage adjacent to the mega shopping mall…

Concrete Robot

Concrete-Eating Robots – The Future of Recycling Old Buildings

The process of demolishing a building involves heavy machinery to crush concrete and separate valuable materials that can be reused. Current methods consume quite a significant amount of time and money in order to safely disassemble the building, extract parts, and transport the materials to off-site centers…

rcon

Why Measure Concrete Resistivity?

Concrete is a porous material which contains microscopic voids known as pores. These pores range in size, vary in connectivity (pore structure) and can be added to the concrete via air-entraining admixtures. The water-to-cementitious material and…

completed road

Open Roads Sooner with Concrete Curing Sensors

Road construction can be a lengthy, disruptive process—so ensuring that your project stays on schedule is one of your most important responsibilities as a project manager. *For eligible new customers only Get a Free Trial Kit…

We use cookies to provide you with a better experience, analyze site traffic and assist in our marketing efforts. By continuing to use this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy Page.